Let’s play a quick game.
You send an email campaign — perfectly crafted, SPF/DKIM/DMARC all green.
But then you check the stats: opens and clicks are way lower than expected.
You: “What? I did everything right!”
Me: “Did you check your link domain reputation?”
You: “…My what now?”
What Is Link Domain Reputation?
Every link in your email is like a reference in a job application.
Mailbox providers don’t just look at your sending domain. They also look at the domains you link to and ask:
- Is this domain trustworthy?
- Has it been used in spam before?
- Is it linked to phishing, malware, or shady marketing?
If the answers raise red flags (yes, it has been used in spam / yes, it’s linked to malware), your deliverability suffers.
If the answers are clean (no, it hasn’t been abused), you’re safe.
But I’m Linking to My Own Site — That’s Safe, Right?
Maybe. Maybe not.
If your domain is brand new, providers treat it as “unknown” until you build reputation. And in email, “unknown” often means “untrusted.”
You: “So my shiny new domain is guilty until proven innocent?”
Me: “Exactly. Welcome to email deliverability.”
Two Key Players in Link Reputation
- Your Own Domain
- Every link — in text, buttons, or images — is scanned. If your site has been blacklisted, hacked, or overused in cold campaigns, your emails get downgraded.
- Third-Party Domains
- Linking to YouTube, Google Docs, Calendly, Dropbox, or news sites? Providers see patterns. If spammers abuse those same domains, your message may be treated with suspicion.
How Mailbox Providers Judge Link Domains
They look at:
- Engagement — Are links clicked? Are messages reported as spam?
- Historical data — Does this domain show up in trusted campaigns or shady blasts?
- Blacklists — SURBL, URIBL, Spamhaus DBL.
- Content safety — phishing flags, malware scans, redirects.
If your links look risky, your inbox placement and engagement take a hit.
Signs Your Link Domain Might Be Hurting You
- Sudden drop in opens after adding new links.
- Spam placement only when certain URLs are included.
- Low clicks even from engaged lists.
How to Protect Your Link Domain Reputation
💡Warm up new domains — ramp up gradually.
💡Use branded tracking domains — e.g. click.yourdomain.com.
💡Check blacklists — MXToolbox, Google Transparency, or EmailConsul.
💡Avoid generic shorteners — unless branded.
💡Scan redirects — make sure they don’t lead to risky sites.
💡Limit outbound links — too many looks spammy.
The Myth of “Safe” Links
Even big brands aren’t always safe. Google Drive, Dropbox, and YouTube links are abused daily. If your message matches spam or phishing patterns, inboxing suffers — regardless of brand names.
Bottom Line: Links Talk
Inbox placement isn’t only about your domain, IP, or content. It’s also about who you link to and how those links perform with recipients.
If your links say, “I’m trustworthy and relevant,” providers reward you.
If they say, “I’m risky or untrusted,” you’ll be talking from the spam folder.
So when deliverability dips, don’t just check SPF, DKIM, DMARC, or your IP.
✅ Check your links.
📈Want to monitor your link domain reputation and see what mailbox providers see?
EmailConsul tracks it for you — so you can fix issues before they sink your deliverability.
🚀 New at EmailConsul: We now also provide open and click tracking to give you full visibility into engagement alongside deliverability insights.
Contact us for details or schedule a demo call here: https://app.simplymeet.me/emailconsul
SimplyMeet.me
Welcome to my scheduling page. Please follow the instructions to add a meeting to my calendar.